A Pill for an Ill Is... Over the Hill
Healing Isn’t Fixing - Because We Are Not Broken Machines
Here’s the Takeaway:
Modern medicine still clings to a model rooted in the idea that each illness has a single, chemical cause—and a single, chemical fix. But we’re not broken machines. We’re living, dynamic ecosystems shaped by sleep, food, relationships, memory, and emotion. Health is more than symptom control. It’s time for a medical paradigm that reflects the true complexity of being human.
📣 Coming in 4 days, watch for “Who’s Driving This Thing?” a follow-up article on the invisible paradigms that quietly steer how we parent, love, vote, eat, work—and yes, even how we think we should smell.
It’s a lighter, sharper look at the hand-me-down rules we live by without noticing—until they no longer fit.
The Old Medical Model: Simple, Seductive, and Stuck
For generations, medicine has been guided by a metaphor: the body as machine.
If something breaks, you find the faulty part—a low hormone, an inflamed joint, a misfiring brain chemical—and fix it. A pill for an ill, as it’s described in my Handbook. A replacement part. A direct repair. It’s a clean, comforting framework.
It also shaped how most of us still think about health:
→ Anxiety? Low serotonin—here’s an SSRI.
→ Pain? Too much inflammation—try an NSAID.
→ High blood pressure? The pipes are tight—take a vasodilator.
The model gave us incredible tools. Antibiotics, insulin, heart medications—all born from this way of thinking. But it also locked us into a view of the human body as a collection of isolated parts and linear problems.
The result? We now have millions of patients on multiple prescriptions, chasing relief from conditions that don’t follow linear rules. Fatigue, brain fog, chronic pain, anxiety, digestive issues, autoimmune flares—symptoms that resist the tidy, mechanical logic of cause and effect. It’s become common for patients to take medicines to treat the side effects of other medications. So, there’s that now.
The Human Body Isn’t a Machine—It’s a Symphony
The truth is: we are not simple machines. We are ecosystems.
Our organs don’t operate in isolation. They communicate constantly—electrically, chemically, emotionally. The gut talks to the brain. The immune system talks to the nervous system. Hormones fluctuate not just with biological needs, but with our relationships, our stress, our light exposure, our sense of safety.
And unlike machines, we evolve. We change with time, with seasons, with experience. We adapt. We compensate. We carry scars—emotional and physical—that shape how we function.
This complexity is not a glitch. It’s the design.
And it means that a reductionist medical model—one that chases single causes and single cures—isn’t just incomplete. It’s limiting. Especially when it tells patients their symptoms are “just in their head,” or worse, that they don’t fit any diagnosis at all.
Why We Got Stuck in the Old Frame
Historically, the mechanistic model made sense. It fit the science of the time.
In the early 20th century, we didn’t have computers, AI, or network modeling. We couldn’t track thousands of variables at once. We treated what we could measure—bacteria, glucose levels, tumor sizes—and designed interventions that were linear and testable.
And it worked. When the enemy was tuberculosis or smallpox or a burst appendix, simplicity was survival.
But the conditions we face today—depression, burnout, metabolic dysfunction, autoimmune disease—aren’t the same. They’re not caused by a single pathogen or a single broken part. They emerge from systems under strain.
And yet, the model hasn’t evolved. Our paradigm still trains physicians to find one problem and prescribe one fix.
When the Map Fails the Terrain
Imagine using a subway map to hike through a rainforest. That’s what modern medicine is doing with chronic disease.
The map isn’t wrong—it’s just for a different kind of journey.
Subway maps help when things are linear, controlled, predictable. But human health isn’t linear. It loops, rebounds, adapts. One signal influences another. The gut affects mood. Trauma affects immunity. Stress affects blood sugar. And everything—everything—changes over time.
We keep treating bodies as if they’re static. As if today’s solution will work forever. But that’s not how living systems work.
Habituation: When the Fix Stops Fixing
One of the clearest signs that the model is broken is this: over time, the very drugs we depend on often stop working.
It’s called habituation. The body, in its brilliance, adapts. Receptors downregulate. Enzymes recalibrate. Tissues become less responsive.
The antidepressant that once brought relief now barely registers. The painkiller that dulled the ache now requires a higher dose. Even hormones and biologics lose their punch.
This isn’t patient failure. It’s biology doing its job—seeking balance in a disrupted system.
But the model doesn’t accommodate that. Instead, we escalate: more meds, stronger doses, new side effects. We keep trying to override the system, instead of understanding it.
The Leftovers of Inflammation
Even when a medicine does help—say, an anti-inflammatory that reduces joint pain—it often quiets just one part of the story.
The core signal may calm, but the downstream mess remains.
Muscles may have overcompensated and developed imbalance.
Posture or gait may have shifted, leading to new pain elsewhere.
Immune molecules called anaphylotoxins may linger, triggering fever, swelling, or itching.
Suppressing a symptom doesn’t erase its ripple effects. It only quiets the alarm.
That may be enough in the short term. But it’s not healing. Healing requires understanding the full arc of what happened—how the body tried to adapt, and what it needs now to come back into balance.
Remember When Medicine Asked Why?
There was a time—not so long ago—when medicine looked different.
Doctors knew their patients. Not just their cholesterol numbers or ICD codes, but their lives. Their losses. Their habits. Their hopes.
The questions weren’t just What’s wrong? but Why now?
What happened? What changed? What patterns do we see?
These relationships were more than rituals. They were therapeutic. They gave doctors the context needed to connect dots—and they gave patients something even more valuable: the sense that they were seen.
But there’s no billing code for that. No reimbursement for listening. Only procedural codes. Diagnosis codes. Fixes.
In the race to optimize care, we’ve industrialized it—and lost its soul.
Toward a New Kind of Medicine
We now live in a world where complexity is no longer a barrier.
Science understands systems. We model ecosystems, simulate weather, map neural networks. We don’t have to reduce everything to a single variable. We can embrace the fullness of what it means to be human.
That means asking better questions:
What’s happening across systems, not just in one organ?
What patterns can we trace over time, not just in the moment?
What life circumstances shaped this health trajectory?
And crucially: What does this person need—not just biochemically, but relationally, emotionally, environmentally—to come back to balance?
Sometimes that includes a pill. But often it includes sleep, movement, nutrition, safety, connection, purpose. It includes living better, not just treating harder.
When the Frame Is the Problem
Here’s the quiet truth: paradigms don’t just describe the world—they define its boundaries.
They tell us what questions to ask. What’s valid. What’s real. What’s reimbursable.
And the “pill for an ill” paradigm has shaped how medicine sees people:
As problems to solve.
As bodies to manage.
As symptoms to suppress.
It’s not that the people are too complicated. It’s that the frame is too small.
Outgrowing Isn’t Betraying
To question the model isn’t to betray medicine—it’s to honor it.
Just as Newtonian physics gave way to quantum theory, our clinical models must evolve. That doesn’t mean we throw out the science. It means we expand it.
We need frameworks that account for:
Interconnected systems
Neuroimmune crosstalk
Psychosocial stressors
The impacts of trauma and resilience
And the full, evolving lives of the people we treat
Because medicine shouldn’t just suppress symptoms. It should help people thrive.
The Future of Healing
So what if we stopped asking only what’s wrong—and started asking what’s needed?
What if we saw symptoms not as failures, but as messages?
What if we understood that real care means not just fixing parts, but restoring the harmony of the whole?
The future of medicine doesn’t lie in more complexity. It lies in finally respecting the complexity that’s already here.
Because healing isn’t just science. It’s relationship. It’s story. It’s biology meeting biography.
And that kind of care? That’s medicine growing up.
🕊 What If “Normal” Isn’t Natural?
❓Why do we believe success means being busy?
❓Why is aging something we’re supposed to hide?
❓Why does everyone assume three meals a day is “healthy,” or that crying at work is unprofessional?
These aren’t facts. They’re inherited frameworks—quiet, persistent paradigms that shape how we live without us even realizing it.
We don’t question them because we’ve been living inside them. But maybe it’s time we did.
⏳ In 4 days, I’ll share my follow-up article: “Who’s Driving This Thing?” The handcuffs of the paradigms we’ve accepted as a species are certainly not limited to medicine. The second half of this piece is a lighter, sharper take on the unspoken rules that run our everyday lives—and how to notice which ones no longer fit.
Below the Paywall: Unspoken Rules That Built the System (and Still Run It)
“You’re not crazy. The rules just don’t fit anymore.”
We inherit these invisible blueprints that feel like truth. Below: a raw, honest look at some other unspoken paradigms still running our lives—and what happens when we finally notice them.
In Case You Missed These:
Upgrade Your Health: How to Use AI to Transform Your Medical Journey
The Shameful State of Modern Journalism: How Low Effort Gets Science Wrong
Unlocking the Secrets of Positive Thinking: How the ECS Could Revolutionize Mental Health
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Doctor Approved to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.